
Overall rating
Filter by
Company size
Time used
146 Reviews

- Industry: Government Administration
- Company size: 51–200 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
Great Service and Support
Reviewed on 2018/12/18
PrimePay is managing our semi-monthly payroll processing needs and tax remittance requirements. The staff are responsive, knowledgeable, and do a great job!
Pros
Service and support are great. Responsive staff and easy tools to support payroll processing.
Cons
I don't have any issues. with the software and have been happy.
Response from PrimePay
Thank you for your review, Jonathan. We take great pride in the service we provide for our clients and are happy to hear that we are meeting your expectations.
- Team PrimePay
- Used Daily for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
Easy to use, good turnaround on responses to issues.
Reviewed on 2018/04/26
Pros
Easy to use, and great report structures. Love that HR3 has carrier feeds. The new timeclock is great!
Cons
My biggest frustration is that there are too many links and no integration between software. You have to get a link to all different services (HR3, PayStubs, FSA, Timeclock) all have different links which frustrate users. Also, as the administrator, you are stuck with having to reach to so many departments because you no longer have a dedicated service manager.
- Industry: Information Technology & Services
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Daily for 1-5 months
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 0.0 /10
Useless to the end user.
Reviewed on 2021/05/07
One word. Shit. I have not been able to access anything I require through your software.
Pros
There is nothing I like about this software and unfortunately the company I work for uses this software. Maybe it works well for them, but from an employee perspective, stone and chisel would be more effective. We I called your helpdesk I was told "we know it's an issue". The is useless. When I asked about accessing MY financial statements the PrimePay help desk tole me they could not help. I have worked for a number of companies that use a verity HR software. Even if other product's UI/UX was terrible, I could still eventually get what I needed. PrimePay's UI/UX is terrible and I CANNOT get the information I need. So for me there are NO pros to the software.
Cons
The frustration and complete lack of support the help desk provided. Their answer was "We know there's an issue. We cannot help but your employer should have the information." I then asked about my 401K and the desk was even more useless saying "I think you need to contact your employer". This is unacceptable and, I, the person requesting their own information, should have access to MY personal salary benefits. Is it even legal for your company to withhold them from me?
Response from PrimePay
Hi Kenneth! Thank you for taking the time to write a review. Although we regret to hear that your experience did not meet expectations, we appreciate you sharing with us so we can improve moving forward. It is our hope that you will give us the opportunity to resolve this issue. We will escalate your specific situation to the appropriate party for this to be addressed. -Team PrimePay
- Industry: Information Services
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 5.0 /10
retrieve tax information
Reviewed on 2021/08/25
call in payroll is excellent...representative very helpful...your website leaves something to be desired.
Pros
good in most areas but TERRIBLE in trying to access up to date information on quarters completed on 940 and 941
Cons
terrible in access up to date quarters completed for 940 and 941 or other tax reported
Response from PrimePay
Hi Rosalie! Thank you so much for taking the time to write a review. We apologize for the experience you've had with accessing Form 940 and 941 data, and we will be sure to use your feedback to improve our efforts moving forward. We will be escalating your feedback to the appropriate party to ensure your issues are addressed. -Team PrimePay
- Industry: Printing
- Company size: 2–10 Employees
- Used Weekly for 1-5 months
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
Still Has The Small Businessman In Sight
Reviewed on 2019/01/17
You can reread my pros for the full monte, but my overall experience in a few words would be "awed by the friendly accessibility."
Pros
That I have found with PrimePay is not limited to the success of their software. While the software is great, it is the people element that I find so refreshing. I used two other well known payroll companies before discovering these guys. The biggest difference I have found is that unlike other payroll companies, they do not vanish once the sale is made. Today was a great example of their friendly demeanor. Even though I knew it was my own fault for not getting payroll in on time, Grace, an account specialist but not mine, cheerfully took my payroll via phone. Happily going the extra step she also took the information for my two new employees who will have their first checks delivered on time tomorrow morning.
Cons
What I like least about this software is my inability to find time to use it.
Response from PrimePay
Thank you very much for your kind and thoughtful review. One of the most valuable things we can offer to our clients is our hands on, passionate client success team. We truly care about each and every one of our clients and whether you have one employee or 100, you will each receive a personalized and caring experience. Never hesitate to reach out to us if you have any questions or concerns.
- Team PrimePay
- Industry: Health, Wellness & Fitness
- Company size: 2–10 Employees
- Used for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 3.0 /10
No response from support after multiple requests
Reviewed on 2020/11/24
Decent payroll software, but you're completely on your own. No support, so if you need any kind of help or have a question, prepare to be on hold for literally hours at a time. Try calling, emailing, submitting a ticket, chat -- doesn't matter -- no one answers or responds. Will be changing payroll companies due to this.
Pros
Mostly easy to use without a lot of accounting knowledge needed
Cons
Some confusing wording when entering payroll information
Response from PrimePay
Hi Lee!
Thank you for providing feedback and letting us know about the issues you are experiencing with support. We are sorry to hear that standard was not met in your interaction with PrimePay. We highly value client feedback and will use this information to improve our products and services. -Team PrimePay
- Industry: Management Consulting
- Company size: Self Employed
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 8.0 /10
Great For Small Business
Reviewed on 2018/12/18
I’ve been a proud customer for over 3 years. Really enjoy the customer service and support. I sleep better at night knowing they take care of everything.
Pros
I love the customer service and hands on approach to providing payroll services. Having access to reports and documents is a plus.
Cons
The online portal could use a make over. It should be more user friendly and easier to use.
Response from PrimePay
Thank you for your kind review, Marcus. We're glad to know that we can take some of the weight off of your shoulders as a business owner and provide you with satisfactory customer support. We are always looking for ways to improve our product. Your feedback is highly valuable!
- Team PrimePay
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 9.0 /10
I love PrimePay! It is an easy to use system that makes running payroll easy and fast.
Reviewed on 2018/01/23
It is really easy to use, and it doesn't take a lot of time to run payroll. Previously, we used ADP and it would sometimes take hours to run payroll. With PrimePay, sometimes it takes as little as 10 minutes!
Pros
I like that it is really easy to navigate, and running payroll can take very little time. It makes it easy to input lots of hours all at once.
Cons
It isn't very easy to verify all of an employee's data at once, since it is on multiple pages. There are reports that can be run, but so far I haven't found a way to get all of an employee's information in 1 place.
- Industry: Religious Institutions
- Company size: 51–200 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 8.0 /10
Cliff's Review
Reviewed on 2019/02/25
I have experience with 5 other payroll systems this is one of the better ones.
Pros
It's reliable, support is decent, friendly
Cons
Some desirable functions are not there. (Ex. can't print an old pay stub) Others are not obvious or easy to use. Reporting is just OK
Response from PrimePay
Thank you for your review, Cliff. We are always working toward improving our system and value feedback from active users, such as yourself.
- Team PrimePay
- Industry: Marketing & Advertising
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 5.0 /10
primepay
Reviewed on 2019/08/30
Pros
Ease of use. They track and file taxes for you.
Cons
Staff is not always knowledgeable or responsive.
Response from PrimePay
Thank you so much for your review, Craig. We are glad you have had a decent experience with us. However, we strive to make it an EXCELLENT one! Please email [email protected] with your company name and phone number. Our team will reach out to you to ensure you have a continued stellar experience with PrimePay. Thanks again!
- Industry: Oil & Energy
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 1-5 months
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 0.0 /10
Worst experience EVER
Reviewed on 2019/10/25
Then after a month of working with them, they did not have direct deposit set up for the second payroll; Friday morning our employees were not paid. I spent the morning at the bank setting up a wire transfer and notifying all of our employees of the situation.
Needless to say, I should have just went with ADP when they initially bought out Wells Fargo. I just completed all documentation to make the switch and I 100% regret ever looking Prime Pays way.
Oh, and when I discussed the endless list of issues with Vice President Of Sales, his conclusion was Murphy's Law. So that gives you an idea of how they'll get to the bottom of your issues over at prime pay.
Pros
there were zero pros with your company.
Cons
I switched to primepay after wells fargo was bought out. I worked with primepay for two payroll runs and I truly don't believe I could have possibly received a more unprofessional experience. Rather than receiving all documents required, they trickled in over the course of two weeks. If they call and you don't answer, expect 4 more calls, voicemails, emails, and texts because they have zero sense of respect for anyone else's time.
I requested a manager in hopes of receiving a more professional experience.. I don't believe there is a single professional in their sales department all the way up to their VP of sales. what . a. joke.
THEN the day I sent over my company's voided check, was the same day my business checking account was compromised (VIA ACH meaning my account number and routing number was used which has never happened before. Thousands of dollars.) I do not believe this to be a coincidence, and I don't believe their emails are secured.
Moving on, I was promised that all of our employees would receive direct deposit beginning on first payroll as all of our employees are scattered across the country on various projects. I started this transition two weeks before payroll was due for this reason. They did not meet this agreement.
- Industry: Accounting
- Company size: 2–10 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 0.0 /10
Change and the Character to Adapt
Reviewed on 2022/03/14
We worked with Prime Pay under the umbrella of a larger organization - however we ran payroll as a separate entity with a separate employer ID # and paid them separately. The organization decided to change, so our last payroll was Friday - March 4. Our logins were cutoff apparently last week and we no longer have access to our reports - It is Monday March 7. I am a CPA in public accounting and I have NEVER seen a payroll company cutoff a customer from obtaining reports even in some of the most unusual circumstances after a final payroll. This tells me about the integrity and character at the top of this company. As a CPA I have a 3 year record retention requirement. I would never refer this company based on this experience. Shame on them.
Pros
No Comment Nothing Questionable Integrity
Cons
If you plan to transition to another payroll company - One can always tell the integrity and character of an organization when you leave a company, what the response to the change is. We have choices - we can retain our integrity, character and professionalism with the many companies that were part of the payroll process or we can spite them and cutoff access to reporting.
- Industry: Music
- Company size: 51–200 Employees
- Used Daily for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 9.0 /10
Awesome
Reviewed on 2018/01/23
Knowing that our employees information is secure and accurate for income and taxes.
Pros
the fact that it is develope with the user in mind as to navigating and the layout of functions. Everything to do with payroll and ACA reporting is made for those that work with it daily.
Cons
There is probably only one thing I would change and that is employer section that allows you to change or update bulk information for employees.
- Industry: Plastics
- Company size: 51–200 Employees
- Used for 1+ year
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 0.0 /10
Links don't work, can't even reset password. Tech support was no help.
Reviewed on 2021/05/26
Well it was a good way to get my blood pressure up. Other than that the website is a total fail. I wouldn't have a job if my product sucked this bad.
Pros
Not one thing, the links they e-mailed don't work, can't even reset password. Tech support was no help they told me I needed to talk to my company administrator didn't even ask if I had an account set up already.
Cons
You could make it so people could reset there passwords, your links work that get e-mailed they take you back to the login page. Which is no help the if you don't recall your password. Tech support tells you have to get with your employer. He told me before I logged in that it probably wouldn't work... Shouldn't have wasted my time.
Response from PrimePay
Hi Walter! We greatly appreciate you writing a review. We are sorry to hear that your experience didn't match your expectations, and we regret that we missed the mark. We value your feedback and will use it to enhance the user experience moving forward to ensure this doesn't happen again. -Team PrimePay
- Industry: Transportation/Trucking/Railroad
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 1+ year
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
Love Prime Pay
Reviewed on 2019/04/11
Overall experience is cool. The best payroll company I have personally worked with thus far.
Pros
The software is easy to maneuver around in and super easy and quick inputting the information in the system. I also love the fact that I do not have to input any information if I do not want to. They have a representative call me weekly and I give her the payroll totals and she inputs the information for me. I then can go in ant any time to review information when needed. They also give out time clocks and can generate the totals from the machine. We will be getting them soon and I cannot wait to try it.
Cons
There is nothing that I do not like about this software.
Response from PrimePay
Thank you for your review, Dawn! We are so happy to see that you are having a positive experience with us. Please let us know if there is ever anything else we can do for you and your company.
- Team PrimePay
- Industry: Medical Practice
- Company size: 2–10 Employees
- Used for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
Easy Life
Reviewed on 2019/01/17
Ive been with Primepay for years now. The company and my "smart representatives" makes my Payroll, Taxes easy. I could have some peace of mind at the end of every pay period and tax year that I am compliant the the IRS and labor law.
Pros
All it takes is a brief phone call, I give the hours and in less than a minute i can download and print out my reports
Cons
Some minor glitches, all is well and well taken cared of.
Response from PrimePay
Thank you very much for your review. One of our goals is to give you time back in your day to focus on what matters most while we handle your back office tasks. We are glad that at the end of the day, you can be left with peace of mind knowing everything is taken care of. Thank you for being a valued part of the PrimePay family.
- Team PrimePay
- Industry: Construction
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
User Friendly Payroll Company
Reviewed on 2019/08/02
Customer service is exceptional for any problems that may arise.
Pros
The software is very easy to use, very easy to navigate through for information and super easy to input payroll. The checks come into my office the very next day and all the direct deposits transfer perfectly.
Cons
The only thing I can say negatively is the reporting. I wish there was an instant work comp payroll report that is more friendly for date ranges for my audits.
Response from PrimePay
Thank you for your review, Elyse! We are so happy to see that you like our user-friendly software. We will be sure to share your sentiments with our team! Have a great day. - Team PrimePay
- Industry: Insurance
- Company size: 2–10 Employees
- Used for 6-12 months
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 1.0 /10
Most frusterating experience ever
Reviewed on 2020/06/04
None I created problems by using Prime pay
Pros
I do not have anything good to say about this software.
Cons
1-833-YOU-MATTER This customer service number does not even dial out. Obviously you as a customer do not matter enough to provide you with a working customer service phone number. I do not and have not ever had access to my pay stub thru Prime Pay. I received emails but was never able to log in and view my own pay check. Do not use this sight if you have a problem no one will help you.
Response from PrimePay
Hi Christina, we appreciate you taking the time to leave a review. We're sorry to hear about your frustration and appreciate that you're letting us know of this issue regarding viewing paystubs. We are working to ensure the login process is easier. You may also visit support.primepay.com for information on how to access your online pay statements.
- Industry: Retail
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Ease of Use
- Likelihood to recommend 1.0 /10
Something Is Wrong
Reviewed on 2019/08/31
I just did
Pros
When operating properly it is very good to view what you
Cons
I am sent a text saying my pay stubs is ready for viewing, but then you will NOT let me log in to check it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! You say "You currently do not have any services linked to your account" REALLY?????????????????????????????
Response from PrimePay
Hi Wayne, I am so sorry to hear you're having an issue accessing your pay statements. We are aware there was an issue last week; again our sincerest apologies. We will escalate this further to make sure your issue was resolved. Thank you!
- Industry: Information Technology & Services
- Company size: 2–10 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 2.0 /10
password reset DOES NOT Work
Reviewed on 2022/01/11
Was great until the fall of 2021. Has been terrible since.
Pros
Pretty good WHEN I can access the my pay statements.
Cons
I have been trying to access my account for over 3 months and quit trying.
Password reset is a JOKE.
The link I received to reset my password defaults to the login screen with no way to set up a new password.
My account as a result locks up.
- Industry: Construction
- Company size: 51–200 Employees
- Used for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
SUPERB PAYROLL SERVICE!
Reviewed on 2019/01/22
Prime Pay has been exceptional in meeting our payroll needs. We have two businesses and both businesses require extra attention each week (on some level). Our payroll representative is superb. 100% of the reason we are still with Prime Pay is a direct result of the customer service we receive.
Pros
I phone in my payroll. I love the aptitude and level of service our representative gives us.
The reports are easy to read.
Cons
The reports are easy to read, extensive yet concise.
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
Extremely user friendly
Reviewed on 2018/04/26
This is my first experience with payroll software, it is so user friendly it makes the payroll process extremely easy to learn and use.
Pros
The program is very self explanatory, and the ease of changing or looking up employees information makes it a pleasure to use.
Cons
Although you can always reach customer service when needed, I find it is hard to contact our representative by phone promptly.
- Industry: Religious Institutions
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 1+ year
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
I use the PrimePay Portal to retrieve Payroll Reports, Tax Reports, W-2 Forms, etc.
Reviewed on 2018/01/23
The most important benefit is the safety and security of all information for our employees. With the PrimePay Portal, I have been extremely satisfied with the security. Secondly, it is very easy to use as I am able to print and/or save the reports/documents as necessary.
Pros
I log in to the PrimePay Portal weekly or at least bi-weekly. I can save or print the reports I need and I believe it is very secure. It is very easy to use. If I need help, which only happened once, the representatives at PrimePay guided me through very easily.
- Industry: Warehousing
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
Best Software on the Market
Reviewed on 2019/01/17
Pros
The ease of access from anywhere I need to work remotely.
Cons
Need quarterly reports faster. I am doing year end and I need reports sooner.
Response from PrimePay
Thank you for your review, Amber! This feedback is highly valuable to us and will be put to good use in improving the service we provide to our clients.
- Team PrimePay
- Industry: Construction
- Company size: 11–50 Employees
- Used Weekly for 2+ years
-
Review Source
Overall rating
- Value for Money
- Ease of Use
- Customer Support
- Likelihood to recommend 10.0 /10
PrimePay
Reviewed on 2019/02/21
Everything is perfect!! Rep is my contact at Prime Pay and she is amazing!! Friendly and very professional. She definitely knows what she is doing!!!!
Pros
I like that all the employee info is all right there
Cons
nothing everything is great! There is really nothing I don't like